Search Pocket PC Life's 126 Pocket PC-related article archive 
Home
EasyPrint
News details Click here for the RSS feed's XML code. This is not a browser URL.
Articles-only Click here for the RSS feed's XML code. This is not a browser URL.
PRODUCT COMPARISON
A tale of three palmtops
By Mark Asadoorian

If you don't already own a PDA (personal digital assistant), chances are good you will wrestle with the two biggest problems faced by potential buyers. The first dilemma is usually the choice of an operating system, namely Palm OS or Windows CE. There is actually another player in this game, EPOC, that holds its own with the best of them, but that's a discussion for another article. The Internet is strewn with message boards devoted to this debate. Of course, each OS has its adherents, and arguments tend to include a lot of pointless blather condemning one or the other. Both operating systems have their strong points and weak points.

I am writing this article based on the assumption that you have made your decision in favor of Windows CE. You are now facing the next hurdle, and that is which machine to purchase. Personally, I enjoy this phase of the buying decision. Since I am an incorrigible collector of portable electronics, I've learned a very important lesson. All of these units are very well made, include lots of extras that increase their value, are well supported, and will do the job required of them. The differences lie in their physical look and feel, and how certain features are implemented.

The heavyweights
There are three heavyweights in the Windows CE palmtop division. The first is the Compaq Aero 2150, shown in Figure A.

FIGURE A

Here's what the Compaq Aero 2150 looks like.

The second is the Casio Cassiopeia E-100, shown in Figure B.

FIGURE B


Here's the Casio Cassiopeia E-100. Roll over picture for a larger image.

The third heavyweight is the Hewlett Packard Jornada 430, shown in Figure C.

FIGURE C


Here's Hewlett Packard's Jornada 430. Roll over picture for a larger image.

Each of these machines offer 16MB of RAM. The Jornada offers a 133 Mhz Processor. The Cassiopeia offers a 131 Mhz processor, and the Aero offers a 70 Mhz processor optimized for Windows CE. The slight difference in processor speeds doesn't seem to make a difference because the apparent speed of all three units is about the same. One thing I did notice is that each unit displayed occasional slowdowns and glitches that seem to be typical of Windows CE, sometimes necessitating a soft reset. I find these glitches fairly aggravating, but most users have accepted this as normal behavior and seem to take it in stride. Each unit features a compact flash slot for additional storage. The Cassiopeia and Jornada screens are capable of displaying 65,536 colors, the Aero displays 256 (the Aero 2180 has the 65,536 color screen). Each of the units has a microphone for voice recording, an infrared port, a stereo headphone jack, and a speaker. Basically, each unit has all the bells and whistles necessary to make it a good value. They each come with bonus software included on a separate CD. Each manufacturer offers different extras including some form of multimedia software. HP seems to have bundled the most extras, including a voice recognition contact manager that allows you to bark a name at your palmtop and have it speak the response to you. Pretty nifty.


1  ·  2  ·  3  ·  Next »
Other articles you might like
Home > Phones and PDAs > Windows Mobile > Devices (14 articles)
   Are you a gadgethound or techno geek? The HTC Advantage might be for you.
   Hands-on with the HTC Touch -- is it an iPhone killer?
   The Cingular 8525 is a top-shelf Pocket PC phone
Home > Reviews > Devices (84 articles)
   Oh, sweet SATAsfaction
   Why we can't recommend the Acer Aspire One
   We review Revell Vexplorer Robotics System
Get Weekly Email Updates
Subscribe to our regular weekly email newsletter. It's packed with tips, reviews, deep analysis, and the latest news.
 
More from the ZATZ journals
Computing Unplugged: Make Mafia Wars an offer it can't refuse
David Gewirtz Online: CNN commentary and analysis
DominoPower: Application development, William Shatner, and the origin of the universe
OutlookPower: Removing an Office installation that doesn't want to go away
-- Advertisement --

ONLINE GROUP CALENDAR - FOR UP TO 100 OF YOUR CLOSEST FRIENDS
Stay organized and in control with 24/7 access to all of your important events, projects and files --whether you're at work, at home or on the road.

You can share your calendar, projects and files so everyone in your office is up to date. Plus, search your entire group to find times when everyone is available to meet, manage company resources and much more.

Organize your entire team for as low as $9.95 per year (and yes, that's where the decimal place is supposed to be!)

Tap here to get started right away.

ZATZ Home  ·  News  ·  Back Issues  ·  Credits/Trademarks ·  Link To Us
Copyright © 1999-2010, ZATZ Publishing. All rights reserved worldwide.
Editor's Login